The different between art and design lie not so much in how they look as in what they do.”(Brady, 1998) How far do you agree with this statement?
Approach: consider the essential difference and similarity between art and design in contemporary art.
Introduction: In the contemporary art, art and design are less likely to be distinguished. Many artists and designers tend to cooperation together. Art work has been wildly applied as elements, using in design work, however, concept of design has been applied to artistic creation as well. Nevertheless, no matter how they cooperation, they are different—the important motive (why and what they do).
Thesis statement: I agree with this statement. Now day, people may hardly to tell the difference between art and design from aesthetic, but the prime motivation of art and design has not been changed.
Paragraph1: Main Idea—the prime motive of art
Evidence—at the earliest art express worship of nature (Hegel), gradually tend to express artist own willing and idea. Even though art in mechanical reproduction age, the artwork be mass produce, the subjectivity of the artist (original work) still are not been changed. ( eg. DADA-cllages)
Sources—The Art of Art History –A Critical Anthology (Preziosi.D)
Paragraph2: Main Idea—the main motive of design
Evidence—the main purpose of design is to promote designer’s products, for commercial. So, it is necessary to consider the cultural roots of any project. As a successful designer must understand the marketplace and needs of clients.
Sources—The Essential Principles of Graphic Design (Millman.D)
Modern British Posters: Art, Design & Communication ( Rennie.P)
History of Modern Design ( Raizman.D)
http://www.webdesignerdepot.com/2009/09/the-difference-between-art-and-design/
Paragraph3: Main Idea—art and design the similarity, cross-over cooperation.
Evidence—with the mass produce has been applied in art, especially in the contemporary art, the artwork has used in the design ( eg. Print the artwork in T-shit or mug ) ; artist borrow the material object from design( eg. Someone else may have invented the wheel, but Marcel Duchamp (1887-1968) invented the ready-made. )
Sources—The Work of Art In The Age of Its Technological Reproducibility (Benjamin.W)
Duchamp ( Janis.M )
The Art of Art History –A Critical Anthology (Preziosi.D)
http://www.webdesignerdepot.com/2009/09/the-difference-between-art-and-design/
Conclusion: contemporary art and design can not be considered as two separate fields in this age, because they play different role in the whole industry separately. Differences in motivation also promote the unique value of art and design, which help these two fields cooperate deeply.